Most trips through the Peace Arch, Pacific Highway or YVR end with a few questions at the booth. When a Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) officer refers you to secondary inspection, however, a different set of rules applies than the ones that govern a police search inside Canada. Border officers can open your luggage and go through your vehicle without a warrant and without any suspicion at all. Other searches, such as a strip search or a look through your phone, require more.
Where those lines sit matters a great deal if a border search leads to criminal charges. A border search lawyer in BC will usually start by asking exactly what was searched, what the officer knew at the time, and what you were told along the way. Below, we explain the legal standards that apply to searches at the border and where CBSA’s authority ends.
Why the Border Is Treated Differently
Section 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects everyone in Canada against unreasonable search and seizure, and that protection still applies at a port of entry. What changes is how much privacy a traveller can reasonably expect. In R v Simmons (1988), the Supreme Court of Canada recognized that people crossing an international border expect to be screened, and that the state has a strong interest in controlling what, and who, enters the country.
Simmons described three categories of border searches, each requiring more justification than the last:
- Routine questioning and the search of baggage, which any traveller can be subjected to without grounds
- Strip or skin searches conducted in a private room after a secondary examination
- Body cavity searches, the most intrusive category, which courts treat with the greatest caution
BC courts continue to apply this framework when deciding whether a search at the border was lawful. Generally, the more invasive the search, the stronger the grounds CBSA must have before conducting it.
What CBSA Can Search Without Any Suspicion
Under section 99 of theCustoms Act, a border services officer may examine any goods being brought into or taken out of Canada. In practice, this covers suitcases, backpacks, purses, packages, and the vehicle itself, including the trunk, glove box, and any compartments. The officer does not need a warrant and does not need to explain why your car was chosen for a closer look. Referrals to secondary inspection can be random.
The Customs Act defines “goods” broadly, and CBSA can detain items while it decides whether they are admissible, whether duty is owed, or whether they are prohibited.
That authority is not unlimited. A routine examination must be carried out for border purposes, such as enforcing customs, immigration and import rules. CBSA’s own guidelines have long stated that officers should not examine items for the sole or primary purpose of looking for evidence of a crime. When a search at the border looks more like a criminal investigation than a customs check, that distinction can become an important issue in court.
CBSA Search Powers Over Phones and Laptops
Phones, laptops and tablets are where CBSA search powers are most contested. CBSA has historically treated a device, and the files stored on it, as “goods” that can be examined under section 99(1)(a) of the Customs Act in the same way as a suitcase. The section sets no threshold for when an officer may do so.
Appellate courts outside of BC have rejected that approach. In R v Canfield (2020), the Alberta Court of Appeal held that section 99(1)(a) is unconstitutional to the extent it allows searches of personal electronic devices without any limits. The Ontario Court of Appeal in R v Pike (2024), found that the provision let officers search some of the most private information a person has without even reasonable suspicion. Neither decision is binding on BC courts, but BC judges can treat them as persuasive when a device search at the border is challenged.
Parliament’s attempt to respond stalled. Bill S-7, introduced in 2022, proposed a new “reasonable general concern” standard for examining personal digital devices. The Senate amended it to the stricter “reasonable grounds to suspect” standard, but the bill then sat at second reading in the House of Commons and died when the parliamentary session ended in January 2025. Border legislation passed in March 2026 amended other parts of the Customs Act but did not address device searches. As a result, the Act still sets no device-specific standard, and the law in this area continues to be shaped largely by the courts.
In the meantime, CBSA operates under its own policy. The agency says it examines devices only when there are concerns that they contain a contravention of border laws, or evidence of one. Officers are required to turn off network connectivity first, and CBSA acknowledges that its authority covers only what is stored on the device itself, not email, cloud storage or social media accounts reached through it. CBSA also expects travellers to provide a passcode when asked, and its guidance allows officers to detain a device for further examination if a traveller refuses. How far these CBSA search powers extend, and what happens to evidence found on a phone searched without proper grounds, are questions that often require careful legal review.
Personal Searches and Strip Searches
Searching your body is a different matter from searching your bag. Section 98 of the Customs Act allows an officer to search a person only where the officer suspects, on reasonable grounds, that the person is hiding contraband, undeclared goods or evidence of a customs offence on or about their body. A hunch or a general sense that something is off does not meet that standard. The officer must be able to point to specific facts.
The Act also builds in protections. Before a personal search, you can ask to be taken before a senior officer, who decides independently whether the search should go ahead. The search must be carried out by an officer of the same sex.
A strip search amounts to a detention. At that point, you must be told why you are being detained and informed of your right to speak with a lawyer and given a reasonable opportunity to do so. Body cavity searches sit at the far end of the scale, must be performed by a medical practitioner, and require the strongest justification of any border search.
Your Border Questioning Rights
Many people assume their border questioning rights mirror what they would have during a police stop. They do not. Travellers are required to report to CBSA, declare their goods and answer questions truthfully. Making a false statement to a border officer is itself an offence under the Customs Act.
The picture changes once questioning stops being routine. Courts have found that where an officer has a strong, focused suspicion and the questioning shifts toward gathering evidence of an offence, the traveller may be detained in the legal sense. From that point, your border questioning rights include being told the reason for the detention and being advised of your right to a lawyer. Statements taken after that line is crossed, without those rights being given, may be challenged.
When a Border Search Turns into a Customs Investigation
If an officer finds drugs, firearms, prohibited material on a device, or large amounts of undeclared currency or goods, a routine examination can quickly become a criminal matter. Border services officers have the power to arrest at the port of entry. Depending on what was found, the file may be handed to the RCMP or to CBSA’s own criminal investigators, who handle customs investigations involving smuggling, false declarations and evasion of duties.
Two separate tracks often run at the same time. One is administrative: CBSA may seize the goods or vehicle and impose a monetary penalty for their return. Those decisions can be reviewed, but the Customs Act sets a 90-day deadline to request a ministerial review. The other track is criminal, where charges are laid and prosecuted in court.
Customs investigations can also extend well beyond the border crossing itself, with follow-up interviews, production orders for financial records, or searches of a home or business. Anything you say to investigators at this stage can become part of the Crown’s case. Our Border Offences page explains the types of charges that commonly arise from these investigations.
Challenging an Unlawful Border Search
Because the border carries lower privacy expectations, some people assume that anything found there will automatically be admissible. That is not the case. When CBSA goes beyond what the law allows, the defence can argue that the search breached section 8 of the Charter and ask the court to exclude the evidence under section 24(2).
Issues a defence lawyer may look for include:
- A phone or laptop search conducted without any articulable reason, or one that went further than the stated purpose
- A personal or strip search where the officer lacked reasonable grounds to suspect concealment
- A traveller who was detained but not told of their right to counsel
- A “customs” examination that was in substance a criminal investigation, sometimes prompted by police
A border search lawyer in BC will review officer notes, secondary inspection records, video from the port of entry and the timeline of each step. Small details, such as when an officer formed their suspicion or when a traveller first asked for a lawyer, can affect the outcome. We explain the exclusion test in more detail in How Evidence Exclusion Works in BC Criminal Cases, and our case results include several border offence matters our firm has handled.
Speak With a Lawyer in BC
The legal standards that apply at the border are different from those that apply anywhere else in Canada, and the law on device searches in particular is still developing. If you have been charged after a search at a BC port of entry, or you are the subject of an ongoing customs investigation, speaking with counsel before you give any further statements can protect your position.
Stern Shapray has defended clients in border cases across the Lower Mainland and throughout British Columbia. Contact us today or call 604-590-5600 to speak with a border search lawyer in BC about your case.